Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s visit to the United States has sparked a range of reactions. The nationalist direction of his government, along with its hostility towards religious minorities and the growing repression of public criticism, have drawn criticism from some quarters. Moreover, India’s continued purchase of oil from Russia, despite the international embargo in response to the invasion of Ukraine, has raised eyebrows. Modi’s refusal to criticize Russia for its military aggression has further fueled the debate. However, these criticisms have not prevented Modi from being accorded a state dinner by President Biden and from addressing a joint session of Congress. Critics argue that these honors undermine the importance of standing up for democratic values and human rights. However, supporters argue that it is essential to maintain diplomatic relations and engage with world leaders, even when there are disagreements and concerns about certain policies and actions. As the visit comes to a close, it remains to be seen how it will impact India’s relations with the United States and the global community.