October 14, 2025

Big news from the Supreme Court on October 13, 2025! The court ruled that the land taken for Tata Motors’ famous Nano car project in Singur, West Bengal, will NOT be given back to the businesses that worked there before the land was acquired. The Bench, made up of Justices Surya Kant and Joymalya Bagchi, reminded everyone of the 2016 Kedar Nath Yadav case. That judgment had ordered the land to return to its original owners within 12 weeks — but only meant to protect the "genuinely defenceless." What does that mean? It means poor farmers, not powerful companies with deep pockets. The court made it very clear: "Extraordinary judicial intervention is warranted when systemic barriers prevent certain classes from accessing ordinary remedies, not when parties possess adequate means to vindicate their rights. Relief conceived to prevent impoverishment among the disadvantaged cannot extend to commercial entities with financial capacity and institutional sophistication." In simple words, if you are a strong business, you must fight for your rights yourself! This ruling came after the West Bengal government challenged a Calcutta High Court order. That order wanted the State to return 28 bighas of land and buildings to Santi Ceramics Private Limited. Santi Ceramics had a big ceramic electrical insulator factory there since 2003 before land acquisition in 2006 for the Nano project. Justice Surya Kant explained that the Kedar Nath Yadav judgment was made for "poor agricultural workers" who lose everything when their land is taken. The court noted that unlike small farmers, Santi Ceramics ran a 60,000-square-foot factory, employing over 100 people, and had bought the land legally for industry. The Supreme Court said, "The restoration remedy was conceived for disadvantaged farming communities, not as general restitution for all affected parties." It warned that allowing companies like Santi Ceramics to claim land back after not fighting earlier would encourage "strategic inaction" where businesses just wait for others to win and grab the same benefits without effort. The court also pointed out Santi Ceramics accepted ₹14.54 crore as compensation long ago without complaint. This showed their "clear acquiescence" to the government's plan. The Bench called their current demand a “classic free-rider problem that judicial remedies cannot encourage.” Now, the judgment allows Santi Ceramics to remove any remaining structures and machines from the land within three months. Or, they can ask the State to auction the property publicly. The company will get the money left after expenses. So, the Supreme Court’s decision is a clear message: legal help and land restoration are meant for those who really need it, not for business giants. The Singur land drama just got a big new twist!

Read More at Thehindu →

Tags: Supreme court, Tata motors, Singur land dispute, Santi ceramics, Land acquisition, Kedar nath yadav case,